Why Students Fail Writing Diagnostics + How to Help

 

There’s nothing more disheartening than administering a writing diagnostic to your students and watching them struggle. Maybe their responses are only a sentence or two long. Maybe what they write barely qualifies as a sentence at all. Or perhaps they simply copy directly from the text—or repeat the evidence instead of adding meaningful commentary.

When the scores come back low, it’s easy to panic. But here’s the truth:

Failing a writing diagnostic doesn’t mean your students can’t write—it means they have skill gaps that need to be filled.

Why Students Struggle with Writing Diagnostics

In my experience, most students who “fail” writing assessments aren’t struggling because they’re unwilling or incapable. Instead, their challenges usually come down to missing foundational skills.

1. Sentence-level struggles

• Students write incomplete or tiny sentences
• Students may not understand how to expand or combine ideas

2.  Paragraph-level struggles

• Students want to repeat the evidence in their commentary.
• Students lack analysis

3.  Essay-level struggles

• Students are overwhelmed by writing an entire essay
• Students get lost in their writing and get off focus.

A writing diagnostic is the roadmap. The results show you where to target your teaching, enabling students to move forward step by step.

Strategies to Build Writing Skills (and How to Save Time Doing It)

When students score low on a writing diagnostic, it's usually not because they "can't" write - it's because they're missing the tools to build stronger sentences, paragraphs, and essays.  Here are 3 practical strategies (with examples) that mirror what's inside the Leveled Writing Lab:

1. Grow Sentences Beyond the Basics

The Problem: Students write only short, simple sentences that don’t show depth.

Teacher Tip: Show students how to combine sentences or expand ideas by adding descriptive words.

Example Activity:

Write two short sentences on the board: “The dog barked. The dog was loud.”

Model combining: “The loud dog barked.”

Then expand: “The loud, excited dog barked quickly at the stranger passing by.”

💡 In the Lab: Students get direct instruction on combining sentences and practice expanding with adjectives and adverbs until they’re confidently writing longer, more descriptive sentences.

2. Strengthen Paragraphs with Sentence Variety

The Problem: Students struggle to move beyond copying from the text or merely repeating evidence.

Teacher Tip: Teach them the “types of sentences” that make up a strong paragraph.

Example Framework:

Topic Sentence: Introduces the main idea.

Evidence Sentence: Pulls support from the text.

Commentary Sentence: Explains how/why the evidence matters.

Concluding Sentence: Wraps it up.

Classroom Example:

Prompt: Why is the character considered brave?

Topic: “The character is brave because she faces danger without hesitation.”

Evidence: “For example, she entered the dark cave alone.”

Commentary: “This shows bravery because most people would avoid such a scary place.”

Conclusion: “Her actions prove that bravery means acting even when you are afraid.”

💡 In the Lab: Students practice writing paragraphs with sentence-type guides so they see what belongs where—making their paragraphs stronger and more organized.

3. Use Essay Building Blocks

The Problem: Students often feel overwhelmed when asked to write a full-length essay.

Teacher Tip: Break the essay into smaller, manageable “blocks” students can stack together.

The Building Blocks:

Introduction Block: Hook + thesis statement

Body Block: Topic sentence + evidence + commentary

Conclusion Block: Restated thesis + reflection/closing thought

Classroom Example:

Prompt: Should cell phones be allowed in school?

Introduction Block: “Imagine trying to learn while your phone buzzes with notifications. Cell phones should not be allowed in school because they are distracting.”

Body Block: “Phones interrupt focus. For example, students often check messages instead of paying attention. This shows that phones make it harder to learn.”

Conclusion Block: “For students to focus, cell phones must stay out of class. Education deserves our full attention.”

💡 In the Lab: Each essay block is taught step by step, so students master one piece at a time before stacking them into a full essay.

---

Why This Matters

These strategies work—and you can try them tomorrow. But here’s the catch: creating scaffolded lessons, examples, and practice for every skill level takes time.  Additionally, there is the immense task of strategically grouping students with matching lessons. That’s why I built the Leveled Writing Lab:

• It provides the direct instruction and practice students need to master sentences, paragraphs, and essays.
• It organizes everything into 9 color-coded levels so everyone gets what they need and can work on their own lesson in the same room at the same time.
• It saves teachers hours of prep because the diagnostics, scaffolds, models, and practice materials are already done for you.

👉 Instead of piecing together strategies on your own, you can open the Lab and know your students are practicing exactly what they need to grow as writers.

✨ Thanks for being here. Teaching isn’t easy, but it matters so much. I’m so glad we’re in this together.

Pin This Post for Later:

Don’t spend hours searching for that great idea you found.  Just pin this to your favorite classroom Pinterest board so you can quickly and easily come back when you are ready.  You’ll be glad you did!